My lifters are noisy, my lifters are noisy, the sky is falling, the sky is falling!
What makes hydraulic lifters noisy? Providing they have the proper preload; the answer is easy – dirt. “Say what – boy? Yo momma could eat off my engine!”
Well, she probably could eat off of your engine parts, but the check valve in the lifter isn’t so lucky. You will note in the exploded view of the lifter, the check valve (disc) is held up against the plunger by a very light spring (emphasis on very light)
Foreign material (dirt) can easily hold the check valve open. As the check valve is only closed by the very light spring.
Lifters (well, Hylift Johnson lifters anyway!) are manufactured and assembled under very strict sanitary (that means clean) conditions (I know, I’ve been there), just to prevent dirt from getting into or on the lifters. Is it possible to get dirt into a lifter? Maybe! Is it possible to get 16 lifters with dirt in them? Yeah, about the same chances as Taylor Swift calling you up for a date! Good luck with that!
So the question is how can the average guy tell if his lifters have been subject to “dirt”.
It is easy if you know where to look, and what to look for.
The lifters have polished areas on their side where they rub against the bore in the block. Normally, this area is POLISHED. Scratches will indicate abrasive “dirt” in the oil.
You will need an 8x or 10x magnification to see the scratches. And no, they are not deep enough to catch with your fingernail. Well… if they are, you got some big dirt, like gravel, in your oil.
The polished area on a flat tappet lifter will be in the same area as the roller lifter. However, the flat tappet lifter should be polished all the way around – as it should be rotating. If vertical scratches are evident, this indicates the lifter is not rotating and will quickly wipe out the cam lobe.
Now, if you install new lifters they may work just fine because all the dirt was filter out by the original lifters. The hydraulic lifters are the best filter in your engines.
If you have scratches here that is a problem -- clean oil will not have scratches!